Friday, March 12, 2010
These Inglorious Bastards...'Truly Indian?'
Ok, No one is allowed to groan....It's another post on food...But I just had to write it....This post is open-ended, hopefully it will bring more dishes to your memory - do send them to me, the most outrageous of them shall find 'meritorious' mention in the annals of my blog. Thanks The Analyst for setting the ball rolling so far as thinking about this post goes...
India and China may not have much love lost when it comes to Foreign Relations...after all they are thought of as the Sneaky Chinese, aren't they? Supplying Pakistan with weapons to fight us with when the Indian intelligence has been distracted by squatters sent across the porous North-East borders so that the map along the far flung boundaries in Arunachal Pradesh and Kashmir can be redrawn with red colour pencil and called Chinese territory!!
Now I have developed a theory that I might put dub 'The Indian School of Action'. Theorising might be a new addition to my repertoire of skills, thanks to the vast amounts of academic calisthenics that you pursue that while you 'read for your MA'.
The question framed: How does India deliver a sucker punch at the more powerful-more prosperous-more enterprising Chinese for their 'outrages'?
Basic Premise: Attack them at what they have become famous across the world for, and mutilate it out of recognition!!!!
Atleast that's what a lot of 'Indian Chinese' cuisine would have you theorise...It's 'authentic' Chinese food cooked in Indian spices, with soy sauce and loads of corn flour to gag an army with as the ingredients that make them Chinese bastards.
And that's how Gobi Manchurian was born. And if the Chinese see it on the menu and think its a tribute to the Gobi desert that stretches barren through a great part of China, well, the ycouldn't be more mistaken!! It's the Revenge of the Indian! Gobi has nothing to do with China, but all to do with how the humble cauliflower is called in Hindi. So you batter fry florets in corn flour till you don't know where the congealed dough begins and the florets end and then dunk them in an unholy sauce made of more cornflour and soy sauce and green chillies with bits and pieces of capsicum and spring onions as floating survivors of the massacre. Now that's the first version that I tasted, later I realised that depending on the Indian cook's particular mood and also his regional location at the moment he was tossing up the dish - the Gobi Manchurian could be red with generous dollops of schezwan sauce also adding to the bastardisation process and instead of capsicum and spring onions, you might be assaulted with huge lumps of soggy cabbage - and all this in enough oil to ensure nothing sticks to the stomach, just uneasily floats around...And then there is the final insult upon injury - garnish with Coriander!!!
And there are more bastards living on the innumerable menus of restaurants big and small across India. How about Schezwan Masala Dosa - (gag, you Chinese devil, gag on what we produce in your name!) Chinese Bhel ( that's the humble bhelpuri where the rice puffs are replaced by fried noodles which are called chopsuey and served by all self respecting Udupi hotels who pride on providing tasty Chinese takeaways) And then there are the Chinese soups which have massive dollops of ingredients non-Chinese including Tamarind and Turmeric....
Ohhh and did I mention Chilly Paneer? Paneer or Indian cottage cheese (very often rubberised as well in South India where they still haven't figured how to make it yet and rely on the ugly little bricks that come frozen in packets) deepfried ( can Indians have anything any other way?) and then smothered in enough green chillies to turn your ears red like the Chinese flag...
Thankfully, since Indians take a rather mild view of tossing up the innards and the entrails of animals and totally look down on frying those pesky grasshoppers that find their way into the house from the garden, many more authentic Chinese food got left alone. Only the bastards managed to thrive successfully here...
But if the Indian massacre of Chinese cuisine made the Chinese gurus wince in pain, then they will take pleasure from the way the Indian gurus are yelping in agony at the British carnage of Indian cuisine...Our pakodas taste here like sawdust batterfried with limp onions, the lamb korma is as sweet as kheer or payasam with as much coconut milk also in it...let me not even mention the Chicken Tikka Masala...the list can go on and on...
Thats my Global Story of Cuisine Massacres...
(P.S: This is not to say that you don't get great Chinese food in India...There are many good restaurants that must make the Chinese feel that there is still some chance for peace talks without filing cases for the genocide of their cuisine at The Hague)
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
Indianized...I think everything of interest in this world to Indians will eventually be Indianized...so much so that people will forget what the original one tasted like!!! That's how we pay you back for invading us one by one and for making India your home.
ReplyDeleteI have heard that the national food of England, the chicken tikka masala is yecch.
a lovely post...I really love your writing.
Very true, and its interesting how the same supposed cuisine tastes very different across the globe. I'm sure you've noticed how different dishes in 'Indian' restuarants in England taste, to the ones that are cooked in Kerala.
ReplyDeleteFor really great, authentic Chinese, go to Gerrard Street in London's Chinatown the next time you are in the West End. It's not expensive but it is superb. I took my wife there two years ago and she still drools when she thinks of it.
this is probably old news but the "chinese" food in india is actually not chinese but "hakka" food sold in the name chinese ... just as everyone from east with slanting eyes to us is chinki so all food made by chinkis ended up being chinese...
ReplyDeleteThanks for the credit, you seem to have taken out your ire on Indo-Chinese food with this post.
ReplyDeleteAnd about the manchurian, Kudos on describing something which has almost no known etymology to date. The version at my college features copious amounts of tomato ketchup as well on this cauliflower-oil abuse dish. The worst fact however, is that this dish almost represents the only vegetarian dish here at my place and I have nearly a year left.
I had thought of an attack on this dish at my blog, but you seemed to have done more justice to Gobi M. with this post.
P.S: If you have a lot of time to kill here's the link to my post (or whatever you like to call it) on Gobi Manchurian, though I must provide a warning that I got a bit vivaciously verbose on the post and the message kind of got lost in translation
http://theanalystquotes.blogspot.com/2010/02/phantom-of-terra-firmapart-1.html
where did my comment go??????????????? :(
ReplyDeleteThis is an automatically generated comment informing that you've been tagged by the analyst for writing a blog with great content. In order to know more on what this means, pay a visit to his blog at http://theanalystquotes.blogspot.com/2010/03/fourth-reich-aka-tag-post.html
ReplyDeleteI read somewhere about a person (An American, I think) who was deputed to China. His Chinese colleague took him to an authentic traditional Chinese (is there any other kind in China :-) ) restaurant. He ordered something that the American would consider exotic. The American stuck to the 'safe' options. But then, the Chinese remarked, 'If a billion people think this is perfectly good food, you should really re-evaluate your biases about food'
ReplyDeleteGreat post. Enjoyed it. The Gobi Manchurian did make me feel hungry :-)
In UK, if you go to an 'authentic' Chinese restaurant, you will realise that all your favourite dishes from 'authentic' chinese restaurants in India taste different...Quiz the chinese here and they say, Oh, this is authentic Cantonese food...Manchurian is very different like Schezuan is...and then you realise all these can be made in all those ways and they are not names of dishes like it is back in India..:)
ReplyDeleteOMG!!! the pics are making me mouth watering and hungry!!!
ReplyDeleteHi Manjunath, thanks for the comment..but if it looks mouthwatering, well then I guess you are all for the inglourious bastards of the food world, i guess...:)
ReplyDeleteIt was really nice to read this post my friend, maybe you can write in my own blog about the same topic but with others words. I"ll love to! Viagra Online
ReplyDeleteyou may even find smaller local independent hotel chains which provide a comfortable stay and charge lower room rates than more well-known ones.
ReplyDeleteLa Rocca Hostels